News | The Investor
9 Jul 2024 5:37
NZCity News
NZCity CalculatorReturn to NZCity

  • Start Page
  • Personalise
  • Sport
  • Weather
  • Finance
  • Shopping
  • Jobs
  • Horoscopes
  • Lotto Results
  • Photo Gallery
  • Site Gallery
  • TVNow
  • Dating
  • SearchNZ
  • NZSearch
  • Crime.co.nz
  • RugbyLeague
  • Make Home
  • About NZCity
  • Contact NZCity
  • Your Privacy
  • Advertising
  • Login
  • Join for Free

  •   Home > News > Business > Features > The Investor

    Readers Love or Loathe Real Estate Fee Idea

    The subject of real estate commissions brings out strong emotions – as reader response to my last column shows.


    In the column I suggested you negotiate commission so that the agent gets much less if they sell your house for less than expected, and much more if they sell it for more.

    Let’s say you and your agent expect your house to sell for around $300,000. A typical commission on $300,000 is $11,900. Propose that for every $1000 more or less you get, the commission rises or falls by $100.

    If the house sells for $250,000, the commission will be $6,900 – down from the usual $10,000. But if it sells for $350,000, the commission will be $16,900, up from the usual $12,900. The agent has much more incentive to get you a high price.

    While several readers loved the idea, one is “extremely suspicious.”

    “If I were trying to sell,” he writes, “I would absolutely expect the agent to underprice the property, pressuring me to accept a lower target price.”

    Maybe. But if you’re selling you should know your property’s approximate value – by checking out similar nearby properties.

    Also, agents tend to set too high a target price when vying for the right to list your house. Don’t propose the new commission structure until contract discussion time, when the agent should be obliged to stick with their price. If they don’t, go elsewhere.

    Sure, once they have the listing, they may use the common tactic of talking down the price in the hopes of making a faster sale. But they’ll be less likely to do that under this structure.

    Another reader wrote, “When I lived in the UK I suggested the same idea to the agency we’d chosen; they were no more interested there than you found here…. Any agency will try very hard not to concede any change of rate, lest it set a precedent.

    “I did see some research that suggested that when real estate agents sell their own houses they hold on longer for a price than the average vendor!” Telling.

    As I said last time, once when I tried changing the commission structure all the local agents refused. And a lawyer has written to say he has been blacklisted by agents for suggesting something similar – including a fairly extreme 1 per cent up to GV and 10 per cent above that.

    Admittedly, these commission structures make life riskier for agents. But if they are good at their jobs, they should come out winning.

    I did manage to convince one agent to do it once – in a tough real estate market quite like the current one. And I know others who have also succeeded.

    Another theme from a couple of readers is that all agent’s commissions are too high.

    “I am surprised that you seem to accept that simply negotiating the transfer of one person's capital asset to another person is worth the average Kiwi's annual income, give or take a bit, in commission,” says one reader. “The defenders of the system (which include, I expect, you), not surprisingly, respond with the predictable ‘swings and roundabouts’ argument. Sorry, this does not cut the mustard with me!

    “I would be interested in your comments on how some agents seem to survive when offering to sell for 1 per cent commission plus advertising.”

    I’m not sure how I got to be a defender of the system that I quite often attack, but never mind.

    Some agents do indeed make heaps. But it’s a free country. You can always choose a cheaper agent, or sell without any agent. If enough people think certain agents are overpaid, they won’t last long.

    © 2024 Mary Holm, NZCity

     Other The Investor News
     12 Sep: Fixed vs. floating rates – which is best for you?
     Top Stories

    RUGBY RUGBY
    The Central Pulse are wary of fast-tracking the return of two key Silver Ferns ahead of crunch time in the ANZ Premiership More...


    BUSINESS BUSINESS
    People can add more veggies on their grocery lists, as prices continue to be cheap More...



     Today's News

    Politics:
    France's Emmanuel Macron asks Gabriel Attal to stay on as prime minister for now 4:37

    Law and Order:
    A Christchurch man killed a stranger he mistakenly believed was trying to kidnap his son from a skate park, felling him with a haymaker-style punch 21:57

    Entertainment:
    Martha Stewart has slammed trolls for branding her mansion makeover "bland and boring" 21:34

    Motoring:
    Motorists are being warned to avoid a serious two-vehicle crash at the Bay of Plenty's Pukehina, on State Highway Two near Rogers Road 21:17

    Entertainment:
    Justin Timberlake is to open a sports bar in Scotland 21:04

    Entertainment:
    Tilda Swinton slapped an American friend who called her "English" 20:34

    Entertainment:
    The Kardashians believe in aliens 20:04

    Entertainment:
    Lupita Nyong'o adopted a rescue cat to help her through a "hard time" and she now can't "imagine life without" him 19:34

    Entertainment:
    Jason Derulo thought he was going to die when he broke his neck 19:04

    Law and Order:
    Two men, including a Auckland Airport baggage handler, have been found guilty of trafficking meth through the airport in 2021 18:57


     News Search






    Power Search


    © 2024 New Zealand City Ltd