News | The Investor
7 Jul 2025 12:08
NZCity News
NZCity CalculatorReturn to NZCity

  • Start Page
  • Personalise
  • Sport
  • Weather
  • Finance
  • Shopping
  • Jobs
  • Horoscopes
  • Lotto Results
  • Photo Gallery
  • Site Gallery
  • TVNow
  • Dating
  • SearchNZ
  • NZSearch
  • Crime.co.nz
  • RugbyLeague
  • Make Home
  • About NZCity
  • Contact NZCity
  • Your Privacy
  • Advertising
  • Login
  • Join for Free

  •   Home > News > Business > Features > The Investor

    Non-Kiwisavers’ Reasons Don’t Stand Up To Scrutiny

    Many New Zealanders who haven’t joined KiwiSavers are missing out on their fair share of the government booty because they misunderstand how it all works. Meanwhile, others in the scheme are not getting as much as they could out of it.


    These two conclusions come from reading a new Inland Revenue report on KiwiSaver. In this column we’ll look at why many reasons for not joining are not valid. Next time – in two weeks – we’ll look at how KiwiSaver members could do better.

    The main reasons eligible people have not joined KiwiSaver are as follows – with my comments added:

    • Almost one third said they couldn’t afford to.

    Two per cent of pay – the minimum employees must contribute – is less than $12 a week if you earn $30,000 and less than $20 a week if you earn $50,000. And after a year, employees can take a contributions holiday and then contribute nothing, or less than 2 per cent.

    Non-employees don’t ever have to contribute anything – although it’s best for everyone to put in up to $1043 a year, to maximise the tax credit.

    There are people who really don’t have any spare money. But not all that many. Consider what would happen if you lost your job and found another that paid 2 per cent less. You wouldn’t starve. As a union official recently said to me, “When members say they can’t afford KiwiSaver, I tell them to cut out a couple of beers a week.”

    • About 30 per cent said there were “either better ways to provide for their financial security, or it was currently better for them to pay off mortgage or student loan debt.”

    I doubt it. Given the KiwiSaver incentives – which double or triple people’s contributions, and more in the first year – it would be a rare investment that performed as well.

    Same goes for repaying mortgages and student loans. Normally it’s great to get rid of debt – especially credit card and other high-interest debt. But number crunching shows you will almost certainly end up wealthier in KiwiSaver than making extra payments on a mortgage or student loan.

    • More than a quarter hadn’t got round to joining.

    For every month you delay, you miss out on up to $87 of government money – as well as compounding returns on all contributions.

    For the young, putting off joining for two years could mean retiring with $100,000 less. Sure, inflation will erode that. But at 2 per cent inflation over 40 years, it would still buy what $45,000 buys today – not a bad round-the-world retirement trip.

    • A quarter worried about lack of security, or that the government may make the scheme less attractive.

    On security, there are KiwiSaver funds run by solid institutions that invest only in government and bank securities. That’s about as safe as it gets.

    On changes, yes, governments are sure to dabble with the scheme. But that’s all the more reason to join now, while it’s so good. If you don’t like future changes, go on a contributions holiday.

    I can’t imagine a government stopping those holidays unless it makes KiwiSaver compulsory. And in that case you will be put into the scheme anyway – and wishing you had joined now, when the incentives were so powerful.

    Interestingly, only 16 per cent of non-KiwiSavers said they hadn’t joined because their money is locked in - usually until retirement or buying a first home. Meanwhile, 32 per cent of members said they joined partly because of the lock-in – presumably because they would otherwise be tempted to spend the money before retirement. It takes all sorts!

    © 2025 Mary Holm, NZCity

     Other The Investor News
     12 Sep: Fixed vs. floating rates – which is best for you?
     Top Stories

    RUGBY RUGBY
    A fuel saving two-stop gamble has paid off for Scott Dixon More...


    BUSINESS BUSINESS
    The Finance Minister says tens-of-thousands of households will be better off - under changes to the FamilyBoost scheme More...



     Today's News

    Motoring:
    Shane van Gisbergen's secured another victory at a disrupted Nascar street race in Chicago, matching his feat on debut in 2023 12:07

    Business:
    The Finance Minister says tens-of-thousands of households will be better off - under changes to the FamilyBoost scheme 11:57

    Politics:
    The Police Commissioner says urgent action must be taken to prevent staff accessing inappropriate or harmful content 11:57

    Entertainment:
    Amal Clooney has praised her husband George Clooney for being "so supportive" 11:36

    Entertainment:
    Allison Williams was "devastated" after one of her Girls storylines got scrapped 11:06

    Entertainment:
    Ariana Madix is constantly seeking "inspo" for her Love Island USA looks 10:36

    Business:
    The Government's expanding the its FamilyBoost scheme, with changes taking effect retrospectively from the start of this month 10:27

    National:
    Elon Musk says he may launch his own party: but US history tells us that’s not a recipe for success 10:27

    National:
    Why Texas Hill Country, where a devastating flood killed dozens, is one of the deadliest places in the US for flash flooding 10:17

    Maori:
    A Maori worldview describes the immune system as a guardian – this could improve public health in Aotearoa NZ 10:07


     News Search






    Power Search


    © 2025 New Zealand City Ltd