News | Law and Order
21 Nov 2024 22:58
NZCity News
NZCity CalculatorReturn to NZCity

  • Start Page
  • Personalise
  • Sport
  • Weather
  • Finance
  • Shopping
  • Jobs
  • Horoscopes
  • Lotto Results
  • Photo Gallery
  • Site Gallery
  • TVNow
  • Dating
  • SearchNZ
  • NZSearch
  • Crime.co.nz
  • RugbyLeague
  • Make Home
  • About NZCity
  • Contact NZCity
  • Your Privacy
  • Advertising
  • Login
  • Join for Free

  •   Home > News > Law and Order

    South African police maintain siege against 'illegal' underground miners despite court ordering access

    A lawyer for the miners sheltering inside an abandoned goldmine says they are suffering from a lack of food, with police poised to arrest them when they surface.


    Starving miners fearing arrest have spent months underground, blockaded by South African authorities who say they are cracking down on illegal operations.

    Police have stopped relatives from delivering food, water and other essentials to those hiding inside an abandoned goldmining operation in Stilfontein, according to the South African Human Rights Commission.

    Reports vary widely about how many people have been trapped in the mine — and how their health is faring.

    Authorities have been unwilling to help.

    A recent court win should have made it possible for relatives to resume sending essentials to those sheltering in the 2.5 kilometre-deep mine for the past three months.

    However, lawyer Yasmin Omar, who has been working to end the blockade, told the ABC that authorities had intensified their siege, and called in defence forces to back up police. 

    Starved miners refuse to leave

    Ms Omar said the government had ordered officers to surround the mine.

    "This is an effort by the South African government to facilitate the ends of their foreign investors in the mines," she said.

    "They are acceding to the request of foreign investors to protect the mine and they are jettisoning or limiting their rights of their own citizens to achieve this end."

    Police wanted to cut off supplies, and force the miners to the surface where they could be arrested.

    "When these guys go underground, the local community, their family members would drop food parcels down and water, blankets, and whatever they thought was necessary, down that shaft and the miners would get food," she explained.

    Authorities said about 1,000 people had come out of the mine, but most stayed in to avoid facing police and prosecution.

    "It became a stand-off," Ms Omar said.

    "So the police said, 'well, look, if we don't give them food for long enough, then if they surely they will come out'."

    The miners have held out, but they have been suffering from a lack of food.

    Last week, a body was pulled out of the mine, Ms Omar said.

    That panicked relatives of those remaining underground.

    They pleaded with officers to allow them to send down food, but police wouldn't budge, Ms Omar said.

    Ms Omar said she wasn't arguing that the miners should not be prosecuted.

    "But we say it's inhumane to trap them down there and take the stance that either you come out and walk into prison with us or you die down there," she told the ABC.

    So far, only three people have been rescued.

    When brought to the surface they reported there were about 4,500 people underground, Ms Omar said she had been told by people at the scene.

    "The numbers are staggering," she said.

    "People told us it's horrendous down there. The people underground are dying.

    "There are dead bodies down there and people are laying next to corpses and it's awful."

    Police have disputed the numbers of those reported to be trapped by the people who have made it to the surface.

    "We feel that the numbers are being exaggerated," police spokesperson Athlenda Mathe said.

    Officials said they believed about 350-400 people were in the mine.

    Authorities don't want to help any of them, but they have been ordered to stop blocking access to the mine — for the moment.

    Court orders police to stop barricade

    Under an interim court order issued on Tuesday, police were told to stop blocking access to the mine so emergency services could enter and those trapped inside could exit.

    Deliveries of crucial supplies like food and water should also be able to resume.

    But it appears unlikely much help would be sent by authorities.

    Cabinet Minister Khumbudzo Ntshavheni told reporters on Wednesday the government wouldn't assist with rescues.

    "We are not sending help to criminals. We are going to smoke them out. They will come out. Criminals are not to be helped. We didn't send them there," Ms Ntshavheni said.

    Ms Mathe said "no police officer, no soldier or government official will go down to an abandoned mine".

    "There is a high risk of loss of life," she said.

    If any miners emerge from underground, police will be ready to detain them, they warned in a statement.

    "All those who resurface will continue to be assessed by emergency medical personnel on site," police said.

    "Those that are in a good health will be processed and detained. Those that require further medical care will be taken to hospital under police guard."

    According to the president of South Africa, Cyril Ramaphosa, some of the miners "may be heavily armed".

    "It is well-established that illegal miners are recruited by criminal gangs and form part of wider organised crime syndicates," he said in a statement earlier this week.

    "The Stilfontein mine is a crime scene where the offence of illegal mining is being committed. It is standard police practice everywhere to secure a crime scene and to block off escape routes that enable criminals to evade arrest."

    He said police would bring the people in the mine to the surface safely.

    Barricade tightens, military called in

    Ms Omar said despite the interim court order for authorities to ease the blockade, it had in fact tightened.

    "The police remained there, and their stance to deny the community access to that entrance to drop food supplies in remained," she said.

    "And in fact, the containment of that area became more intense. They called the South African National Defence Force, they called the ministry in and it just made the situation a lot more tense and a lot worse."

    Ms Omar said authorities had also stopped some of her staff from going to the site to update relatives on legal proceedings.

    Military personnel told her staff the area was closed from 5pm, she said.

    "Our country boasted that we were a free people that we're not going to let the the events of the past like what happened during apartheid be repeated in our country," she said.

    "And to us, it smacks of exactly that. We've now got curfews. We've got people in lockdown when it's not necessary. We've got the military descending into civil society."

    A further hearing at the High Court in Pretoria has been set down for Thursday.

    The South African Human Rights Commission has also launched an investigation into how the police have handled the situation.

    Why are people in an abandoned goldmine?

    The government calls the people trapped underground "illegal" miners.

    Since mid October, there has been a renewed crackdown on illegal mining operations, focused in the North West Provice where the Stilfontein mine is located.

    David Van Wyk, a lead researcher at Johannesburg-based Benchmarks Foundation, told CNN there were about about 6,000 abandoned mines across South Africa.

    They become targets for illegal mining if they are not properly closed down by the large, multinational corporations that ran them, he said.

    Ms Omar told the ABC that impoverished people were often recruited by criminal gangs to go into closed or inactive mines.

    "They … tell them if you go underground, we're going to pay you to pull out certain things that we want from underground," she said.

    She said it was yet to be determined if those in the mine knew they were involved in an illegal operation.

    "They may truly be really clueless about the legality or illegality of their actions, and that is the criminal standard that must be met," she told the ABC.

    "For them to be found guilty of doing something illegal … it would have to be shown that they intentionally — knowing that this is illegal — entered into that mine."

    Illegal mining is common in South Africa's old gold-mining areas, with miners going in closed shafts to dig for any possible remaining deposits.

    Their presence in closed mines has also created problems with nearby communities, which have complained the illegal miners, who are often from neighbouring countries, commit crimes ranging from robberies to rape.


    ABC




    © 2024 ABC Australian Broadcasting Corporation. All rights reserved

     Other Law and Order News
     21 Nov: Accusations of evidence planting, false statements, and acting in the Defence cross examinations at the murder trial of Tingjung Cao
     21 Nov: Illegal immigrant gets life sentence for murder of Laken Riley highlighted by Donald Trump campaign
     21 Nov: A successful first day for the gang patch ban
     21 Nov: Susan Smith, South Carolina mother who killed two sons in 1994, denied parole after 30 years behind bars
     21 Nov: Several recommendations from a coroner, in light of a Takaka truck driver's workplace death
     21 Nov: A Head Hunters associate faces serious charges after a rampage in east Auckland last night
     21 Nov: Philippines to repatriate Filipina drug convict Mary Jane Veloso
     Top Stories

    RUGBY RUGBY
    Former Canterbury representative Blair Murray will start at fullback for Wales in Sunday's test against South Africa in Cardiff More...


    BUSINESS BUSINESS
    New Zealanders can now make contactless payments entirely on iPhones More...



     Today's News

    Law and Order:
    Accusations of evidence planting, false statements, and acting in the Defence cross examinations at the murder trial of Tingjung Cao  21:57

    Entertainment:
    Scott Mills feels honoured to be replacing Zoe Ball as the host of BBC Radio 2's 'Breakfast Show' 21:39

    Motoring:
    There's serious injuries... after two vehicles collided on State Highway One, near Palmerston North 21:17

    Entertainment:
    Fiona Shaw insists "the dial is turning" for women in television 21:09

    Law and Order:
    Illegal immigrant gets life sentence for murder of Laken Riley highlighted by Donald Trump campaign 21:07

    Entertainment:
    A New York priest who let Sabrina Carpenter film her 'Feather' music video in his church has been stripped of his duties 20:39

    Entertainment:
    Barry Keoghan began enjoying life more when he stopped "making excuses for stuff" 20:09

    Entertainment:
    Ben Affleck thinks movies will be "one of the last things" to be replaced by AI 19:39

    Entertainment:
    Cynthia Erivo was "annoyed" by Dax Shepard's "inappropriate" question about her long nails 19:09

    Accident and Emergency:
    A person has serious injuries after a crash between a car and motorbike in Marotiri, northwest of Taupo 18:57


     News Search






    Power Search


    © 2024 New Zealand City Ltd